Psychological Healing
in the Roman Catholic Mystic Tradition

Questions and Answers

When I yield to my spirit’s yearning for intimacy with the divine, I feel driven to purge from my life anything that might be idolatrous, that is, anything with which I identify that might be a hindrance to intimacy with God—friends, affections, habits, my name, my membership to certain organizations (i.e. the military), essentially, most of what makes me me.

While there is obviously Biblical merit to separating from sin and idolatry in the pursuit of God and realizing by faith our identity in Him, it is the draconian and ruthless manner in which I feel driven toward such separatism by what I perceive to be God’s Spirit that unsettles and repulses me.

The fruits of the Spirit and the wisdom and will of God, as detailed by the New Testament writers, are expressed through agape love and are “heavy” on gentleness, compassion, truth spoken in love and an effort to only do what is honorable and good in the eyes of all. So why do I sense a calling to tell others whom I have shared a spiritually errant past that they are dead to me and then treat them as such, and speak the “truth” without tact, consideration and thought of its “benefit” for others in my dealing with the world?

I have read countless spiritual works over the past decade by those who made “knowing God” their single-minded desire. The guiding principle for these men and women seems to be an uninterrupted receptivity to His presence and hearing His voice. Many seem to echo my own spirit’s desire to cast aside with severity anything that would distract this singleminded attention to the indwelling Spirit of Christ.

When I read the Scriptures, however, love for God is to be expressed through love for our neighbor. Even abiding in Christ, as portrayed in the Vine and the Branches metaphor in John 15, seems contingent upon obeying the command to love our fellow believers. While the love of God for us is the driving force for love for our neighbor, the pervading theme of the New Testament seems to be that it is through love for humanity, particularly other believers, that we experience this love.

This is the paradox of love which first drew me to seek out Christ in earnest.

My basic dilemma: I “want to want” to yield to, receive and reflect God’s love for a the world through the selfless avenues of truth, gentleness, compassion, grace, sacrifice, and wisdom, but I sense in my spirit that I am being led to cast those considerations aside in drawing close to God.

It is as if God is asking me to unlearn my conception of love, which is rooted in my own insecurities and brokenness, and while I welcome such healing, I resist, stating in my heart that while I may not know what love is, I “know what it ain’t,” specifically, a cold and callous treatment of others, even in the pursuit of God. While I realize a relationship with God isn’t based on the law, I fail to understand why intimacy with Him would contradict the law of love.

I long to experience the love of God through love for others, not at their expense, and so I press on in self-effort and erratic spirituality, rather than receptivity to His Spirit. This is not a “dark night of the soul,” but more a cathartic and at times blasphemous wrestling with God. I fully realize that at the root of my resistance is something self-protective and distrustful of God, where my deepest healing and liberation needs to take place, but that does little to negate the reality that treating others in an unloving manner seems uncharacteristic of Christ, no matter how impure or insecure my motive. If I am honest, I essentially refuse to believe that the end (intimacy with God) justifies the means (draconian separatism and emotional insensitivity toward others). Moreover, I refuse to follow that God in intimacy even though I know this is the only God I have.

 
You speak very well, from your own experience, about a core psychological problem in living a genuine Christian life. In fact, I have reproduced your long question almost in its entirety so that others may be able to recognize the basic problem about detachment from the world. To help you grasp the solution to this problem, consider a similar problem from medicine.

When an epidemic breaks out in a society, individuals must do what they can to protect themselves from contamination by infectious viral or bacterial agents. Because these agents are passed on through physical contact with infected sources, the best method of protection usually amounts to some form of isolation from individuals already infected.

Notice carefully, however, that protection from infection derives from separation from infectious agents, not from other persons in and of themselves. It should be clearly understood that other persons, even those infected, are not “bad.” But, since they carry infection, they must be avoided in order to avoid infection.

Now, to live a holy life, we must avoid contamination by anything unholy. Unlike medical infection, however, spiritual “infection” does not come specifically from physical contact with other persons. Nor does it come from physical contact with “unclean” things; in fact, Saint Peter had a vision (Acts 10: 9-16) in which this was made clear to him. Spiritual infection comes from contact with the desire to sin.

Please understand here that desire is not a bad thing. God created us so that we could desire Him through pure love. But, because of Original Sin, human desire has been corrupted; when we are outside a state of grace, our desire for God is obscured by our desire for sin. And so, to live a holy life we must separate ourselves from the desire to sin.

To achieve this separation from the desire to sin, we first must use all the resources of the Church to repent our sins and return to a state of grace. Then we must take precautions that we do not become reinfected by the desire to sin.

To avoid reinfection by the desire to sin, we must avoid television, movies, sports, bars, newspapers, magazines, and every other aspect of “popular” culture, because these things are filled with a massive craving for everything unholy and have their basis in an indifference and contempt for anything holy.

Detachment from the desire to sin, though, does not mean that we must avoid those persons who are caught up in these desires as if those persons themselves are “bad”—we avoid such persons because of the infection of sinful desires they spread about them. A person seeking holiness avoids such persons (to the extent socially possible, considering work obligations) and prays for their repentance and conversion out of love for them.

Thus you can see that there is no discrepancy between detachment from the world and holy love for the world. To love the world with divine love you must pray constantly for the conversion of the world, and, in order to be able to pray constantly, you must remain detached from all that is not conducive to holy prayer. There’s nothing ruthless or cold-hearted about any of this.

If any discrepancy does arise between detachment and love, it’s the result of pride. Pride is simply the narcissistic desire to stand apart from others to be noticed for oneself. As you mention, pride can trick us into believing we are doing God’s will when really we are serving our own self-interests. You can best protect yourself from the sin of pride by cultivating the opposite virtue: humility. Think of humility, in its essence, as such a complete awareness of the awesome mystery of God’s love that you have no other desire than to be detached from all that is not holy and to pray constantly for the conversion of all that is not holy. Pride, you should note, seeks only its own glory and does not know how to pray for others—it might cause you to speak the words, but your heart will remain cold, hard, and aloof.

Therefore, you certainly can “yield to, receive, and reflect God’s love for the world through the selfless avenues of truth, gentleness, compassion, grace, sacrifice, and wisdom.” You do this by a humble detachment from the desire to sin while praying constantly for those caught up in the desire to sin. That’s love. That’s what you have been seeking all along. It’s not a paradox, but it is often misunderstood by those who don’t want to do the hard work of praying constantly because, in not detaching themselves from the world, they continue in their desire to sin—often outside their own conscious awareness.

 


 Back to the list of questions

 


 

DID MY WORK help you? Have you found insight into your behavior? Have you found information unlike anywhere else? Then why not make a Quick & Easy donation to this freewill website to express your gratitude for my labor in creating something substantial, something that can change your life for the better?

Huh? Donations? Freewill website?
What’s this about?


No, you cannot place your ad here, because I refuse to sell advertising on this website.


 

Chastity

In San Francisco?

www.ChastitySF.com

CATHOLIC PSYCHOLOGY

in association with
A Guide to Psychology and its Practice
 
Copyright © 1997-2008 Raymond Lloyd Richmond, Ph.D. All rights reserved.
San Francisco, California USA